BUT if you take one every day you'll find that you require one to sleep. The doctor prescribes a sleeping pill to help you sleep. ![]() Whistle tabs are helpful at first, then very soon become harmful. The OP's post and the comments here are right on. Oh! And I find it much easier to memorize music from tabs than sheet music, which is a big help. For some people whistle is a more casual hobby and that’s ok too. It’s certainly worth doing but it’s not for everyone and that’s ok. And no, learning to read anything beyond simple nursery rhyme music is in fact not simple and easy for everyone. ![]() They also make music more accessible to people who don’t know how to read music or don’t have the time or interest to do so. Plugging letters into a tab maker is waaaay faster and easier for this type of thing. All I need are the notes cause I know the song already. When I’m making a cover of a song I like, I don’t need to write out all the note details on sheet music. I enjoy being able to easily switch keys without needing to think about it or write out a transposition and they are easier and faster to both read and write by a wide margin. These are all my thoughts and opinions, and I'd be interested to hear if anyone else has some thoughts on the topic.Īs someone who absolutely knows how to read and write music and has been for over 10 years- I almost always prefer tabs. What's more, if you ever go on to learn another instrument that isn't the flute (as many whistlers choose to do), tab notation will become totally useless to you.Īgain, I'm not saying to never look at another whistle tab again, but if you're a beginner or intermediate player that feels like you need tabs to learn or play, it might be worth weaning yourself off of them sooner rather than later. They don't exist for every tune, they're difficult to write on paper, your fellow non-whistling musicians can't read them, and constantly translating ABCs or MIDIs into tabs is a pain. Tabs quickly become cumbersome if you're overly reliant on them. I think the biggest benefit of ABC and Standard notation is the practical bit. Granted, seeing rhythm on paper is no substitute for hearing it, but at the very least you're reminded it's there. ABC and Standard also communicate rhythm and note groupings in a way that tabs can't. I've seen more than a few posts from people asking why it sounds wrong when they try to play along to a tune, only to find out they're playing a Bb whistle to a tab video made with a D whistle. For one, they both force you to think about music as a series of notes rather than a series of finger positions. In my opinion, tabs aren't the best form of written music to use (if you're going to use any at all), and I'd encourage players to become familiar with either standard or ABC notation as they learn. I use written music all the time when I'm having trouble making out a tricky bit by ear, or making note of variations, or even just jotting down the first few notes of a tune I can't remember how to start. Written music certainly plays a useful role too, even the purists will (begrudgingly) admit that. It's never too early to start, and for trad players especially it's a skill that pays huge dividends as you get better at it. That being said, I've been seeing a lot of content aimed at intermediate players that relies on tabs to do most of the teaching, and I think there are some good reasons why players might want to move away from tabs as you learn and improve.įirst, as I'm sure most people have heard repeated ad nauseam, learning by ear and playing from memory are two essential skills most players should strive towards. ![]() You'll never hear me saying that tabs are bad in fact I think they do a lot of good making the music more accessible and subtly teaching your ear where the notes are. ![]() I've seen a lot of tab content floating around whistle communities recently and I thought I'd share my thoughts on them and open the floor for discussion.įirst, let me say that I think tabs are an incredibly helpful resource, especially for new whistle players and double especially if whistle is your first instrument.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |